|
Nov 4, 2007 |
|
|
|
Why did KNEA/NEA channel $130,000 to the Kansas Alliance for Education PAC in 2006? |
|
|

Related: Lawrence Journal-World Editorial, Nov 4: Board pendulum
Summary: In the 2005-2006 election cycle, a new group, Kansas
Alliance for Education (KAE), formed to oppose all conservative candidates for
the Kansas Board of Education, and had a dramatic impact on those
races. (See a brief chronological history
of KAE, and political info about the KAE
Board below.) While KAE's initial focus was the
Kansas Board of Education, KAE formed a coalition with a number of
left-leaning groups to promote political change in Kansas. These
affiliated groups included:
KAE raised a lot of political money. The summary by reporting period below shows KAE raised $194,476 for only five State Board of Ed contests held in 2006. Almost two-thirds of KAE's money, $130,000, came from KNEA/NEA sources, with nearly one-third of the contributions from about 285 individuals. These KAE individual contributors wear a "moderate" public mask but are left-leaning, if not far-left, in their political support. The far left-leaning MAINstream Coalition PAC provided $9,000 in in-kind support to help with mailings, and gave KAE $1000 cash. Kansans for Lifesaving Cures was the only other PAC contributing money to KAE and they gave $2000. The $5500 KAE gave to SBOE candidates was all the official Kansas Governmental Ethics report showed about KAE's expenditures, but KAE spent a total of over $182,000 to knock out conservative State Board of Ed candidates. KAE spent nearly $83,000 in printing and postage (and received another $9000 for printing and postage from MAINstream Coalition). KAE spent nearly $35,000 on radio ads in seven different radio markets around the state, with another $9000 spent with a Denver firm for ad production. KAE spent about $27,500 to pay the salary of staff member Craig Grant to help with their campaign. [Grant is a former KNEA chief lobbyist and political director, and "independent contractor" for the Kansas Democratic Party earlier this year.] Finally, KAE spent about $7500 on get-out-the-vote phone calls. KAE and their left-leaning friends played a full-court press on the voters on Kansas. The focal point of KAE and the left's political wrath last year was Connie Morris in the 5th State Board of Ed District in Western Kansas. With KAE's help, Morris was edged by Sally Cauble in the August primary, who went on to win the November General election. Oddly, KAE endorsed both Democratic and Republican candidates in District 5. They wanted anyone but conservative Connie Morris. The endorsement page from Sally Cauble's web page, with comments about those making the endorsements, tells much of the story of what happened last year in State Board of Ed races:
|
|
The focal point of the left's
political wrath was Connie Morris in the State Board of Ed 5th District. |
|
|
Comments about groups endorsing Cauble (in the same order as
above):
The far-left complained about the "ultra right" conservative State Board members, and religious beliefs the far right was imposing on government schools in Kansas through the Board of Education. But, MAINstream Coalition, a group pushing for separation of religion and government, and who sent church monitors into churches to make sure conservative ministers were not abusing their 501(c)3 tax exempt status, held their first "Take Back Kansas" meeting in a church in Lawrence to push a KAE, and a left-leaning agenda on Kansas, as mentioned on a Lawrence blog. Why didn't anyone in the press report on the irony of that meeting being held in a church? KAE opposed the "religious agenda" of the "ultra right" conservative State Board members, but KAE on their web site mentioned the religious affiliation of several members of their board? Why? If the religious affiliation of the current State Board of Ed members offended KAE, why should KAE impose on Kansas the beliefs of their members based on their religious affiliation? If the KAE is trying to make secular arguments about education, why do they list the religious affiliations of some of the members of their board? How is replacing "far right" conservative board members any better for Kansas than a "far left" liberal board KAE is supporting? MAINstream Coalition and KAE are already having public meetings in in late 2007 setting the stage for the 2008 political campaign. With their successes from 2006, KAE is likely to use many of the same tactics in 2008, including using a huge amount of NEA/KNEA money in political contests. While KAE currently says their focus is on State Board of Education races, what's to keep them from expanding their goals and political influence to all Kansas elections, including State Representative and State Senate races in 2008?
|
|
1. Brief Chronological History of Kansas Alliance for Education According to their web site, "The Kansas Alliance for Education (KAE) is a nonpartisan grassroots organization formed in 2005 for the purpose of promoting the election of candidates to the Kansas State Board of Education who support quality education for all Kansas children."
|
2.
Political Profile of Non-Partisan Kansas Alliance for Education
Executive Committee and Board
| Executive Committee | |
| Don Hineman, Dighton | Republican;
Farmer and rancher; past president of Kansas Livestock
Association;
|
| Rosemary Clary, Johnson | Republican; Former regional vice president of Kansas Association of
School Boards
|
| Don Anderson, Lindsborg | Democrat;
|
| Betsy Hineman, Dighton | Republican;
Parents as Teachers Consultant for Kansas Department of Education;
|
| Ward Loyd, Garden City | Republican.
Former State Rep 123
|
| Dick Morrissey, Lawrence | Democrat.
Worked in public health; KAE contributor.
|
| Terry Woodbury, Leoti & KC, KS | Unaffiliated voter; Founder and President of Kansas Communities, LLC. Former President/CEO of WyCO United Way |
| Frank Alexander, Hutchinson | Republican. Founding member, Reno County 2000, a Community Partnership for Educational Excellence |
| Dick Bond, Overland Park | Republican.
Former Kansas Senate President;
|
| Jim Braden, Clay Center | Republican; Former
State Rep, House Speaker; KAE contributor
|
| Vern Chesbro, Ottawa | Republican; Former
KS GOP Chair; Trustee and Chairman of KPERS, 1984-2004;
|
| Rochelle Chronister, Neodesha | Republican; Former
State Rep; past Secretary of Kansas Social and Rehabilitation Services
|
| Tim Cruz, Garden City | Democrat; Former
Mayor of Garden City; Trinity Lutheran Board Directors;
|
| Joyce Cussimanio, Girad | "Unaffiliated"
voter;
|
| Ray Daniels, Kansas City | Democrat;
Superintendent Emeritus of Kansas City, KS School District;
|
| Tom Docking, Wichita | Democrat; Former
Lieutenant Governor;
|
| Barry L. Flinchbaugh, Ph.D., Manhattan | Republican; KAE
PAC contributor
|
| Linda Frick, Scott City | Republican; President of Scott City School Board; KAE PAC contributor |
| Charles Frickey, Oberlin | Republican; Lutheran church leader in Oberlin and Northwest Kansas; KAE PAC contributor |
| Craig Grant, Lawrence | Democrat;
|
| Dr. R.V. Haderlein, Girard | Republican;
|
| Dr. Robert Harder, Topeka | Democrat;
volunteer lobbyist for the United Methodist Church, KS; ordained
minister, United Methodist Church;
|
| Clark Harris, Tribune | "Unaffiliated" Voter; Greeley County Board of Education |
| Sue Ice, Newton | Republican; Former Member of
Newton School Board; Newton Presbyterian Church Elder;
|
| Dan Johnson, Hays | Republican; State Rep
District 110;
|
| Janis Lee, Kensington | Democrat; State Senator
District 36;
|
| Mildred McMillen, Tonganoxie | Democrat; former member of Kansas State Board of Education |
| Bob Meneilly, Prairie Village | Democrat (former
Republican for Moore but switch parties in late 2006); Founding Pastor of
the Village Presbyterian Church in Prairie Village;
|
| John Nalbandian, Lawrence | Democrat; Former Mayor of
Lawrence;
|
| Ligia Paquette, Junction City | Republican; 40 years public
school experience in Kansas and Puerto Rico
|
| Ethel Peterson, Dodge City | Democrat; Former State Rep
District 119;
|
| Pat Ranson, Wichita | Former State Senator; Republican;
|
| Louis Ruiz, Kansas City | Democrat; State Rep District 32 |
| I.B. “Sonny” Rundell, Syracuse | Republican; former member of
Kansas State Board of Education.
|
| Roonie Sellers | Kansas Action for
Children Board Member; First Presbyterian Church Elder
|
| Philip Shull, Wichita | Pastor, University
United Methodist Church
|
| Mark Smith, Wallace | Board of Northwest Kansas Technical School; |
3. Summary of KAE PAC Money Raised, Spent, and Balance
| Reporting Period |
$ Raised | $In-Kind | $ Spent | $ In the Bank |
| 2006-01 | $16,749 | $19 | $759 | $15,989 |
| 2006-07 | $98,391 | $32 | $86,361 | $28,019 |
| 2006-10 | $78,286 | $7,048 | $83,908 | $22,398 |
| 2007-01 | $1,050 | $2,044 | $11,076 | $12,371 |
| TOTAL | $194,476 | $9,143 | $182,104 |
4. Summary of Expenditures by Kansas Alliance for Education
| $82,714 | Record Publications (KCK) / Record News (Basehor), printing and postage |
| $34,983 | Radio ads in Chanute, Colby, Dodge City, Emporia, Goodland, Nevada (MO), Pittsburg, Wichita |
| $28,082 | Craig Grant salary ($27,500) and travel ($582); See info about Grant above. |
| $11,943 | CCAdvertising, Herndon, VA, surveys |
| $9,000 | SKEWmedia, Denver, CO, ad production |
| $7,545 | Get-out-the-vote
calling: $7089, Next Big Thing, Leesburg, VA $456 Djarling Communications, Denver, CO |
| $5,500 | Contributions to SBOE
candidates: Cauble, |
| $783 | SpiderWebDesign, Weskan, KS, web site design and update |
| $480 | KS Governmental Ethics Commission, registration fees |
| $452 | PayPal Transaction Fees |
| $181,482 | Partial Expenditure TOTAL |
| The $182,104 spent by KAE is almost $69,000 more than what was spent by the #2 PAC in Kansas in 2006. This shows the Top 20 PAC Contributor List does not accurately reflect political involvement in Kansas. The problem in official Kansas reports is even more clear in the "Aggregate Total for Calendar Year 2006," which only shows the $5,500 contribution to candidates and ignores nearly $176,000 in other spending. |
Expenditure Report from Kansas Governmental Ethics Commission
5. Notable Contributors to Kansas Alliance for Education: PACs and Individuals
| Date | Amount | Contributor | Comments |
| NEA (DC) / KNEA (Topeka) | |||
| 3/1/2006 | $25,000 | KNEA-PAC 715 SW 10th Ave Topeka 66612 |
Kansas
National Education Association PAC is #1 Kansas PAC in 2006 and participated in funneling money to Kansas Democrats in 2006 |
| 6/5/2006 | $10,000 | ||
| 7/1/2006 | $25,000 | ||
| 9/21/2006 | $25,000 | ||
| 10/23/2006 | $7,500 | ||
| 8/18/2006 | $15,000 | The NEA Fund 1201 16th St NW, Suite 421 Washington, DC 22036 |
National Education Association PAC |
| 9/25/2006 | $22,000 | ||
| 6/30/2006 | $500 | United Teachers of Wichita PAC |
95.2% of funds from KNEA
in 2005-2006 election cycle: Received $6564 from KNEA and $358 unitemized |
| TOTAL | $130,000 | ||
| 7/31/2006 | $5,000 | The MAINstream PAC Leawood |
in-kind contribution: postage at The Record |
| 9/29/2006 | $2,000 | The MAINstream PAC | in-kind contribution: postage at The Record |
| 10/31/2006 | $2,000 | The MAINstream PAC | in-kind contribution: printing and mailing at The Record |
| 11/6/2006 | $1,000 | The MAINstream PAC | monetary contribution |
| 10/23/2006 | $2,000 | Kansans for Lifesaving Cures | |
|
Selected Individuals |
||
| $450 | Phil Acuff, Prairie Village | Kansas Traditional Republica Majority (KTRM) contributor |
| $250 | Suzanne Allen, Mission Hills | Contributor to MAIN*PAC,
Morrison, Kansas Families
United for Public Education (KFUPE), KTRM; former Planned Parenthood Board of Directors |
| $500 | Mary Jo Allen, Lenexa | MAINstream contributor |
| $200 | Gary Anderson, Prairie Village | Contributor to Sebelius, Morrison, KTRM |
| $100 | Eliot Berkley, Fairway | Contributor to MAIN*PAC,
Dennis Moore; Planned Parenthood Advisory Board |
| $800 | Irene Bettinger, Mission Hills | Contributor to MAIN*PAC, Dennis Moore,
ProKanDo; Republican for Moore (2000, 2002, 2004) |
| $500 | Michael Blumenfeld, Lawrence | Contributor to Sebelius |
| $350 | James Braden, Clay Center | Contributor to KTRM; former KS Speaker of House |
| $100 | Margot Ann Breckbill | Contributor to Sebelius, DollarsForDemocrats,
ProKanDo; Kansas Action for Children Board of Directors |
| $100 | Doris Brown, KCK | Contributor to MAIN*PAC, ProKanDo |
| $240 | Kay Callison, Prairie Village | Contributor to Mainstream, Emanual Cleaver (Democratic Missouri Congressman) |
| $500 | Kay Carmody, Lawrence | Contributor to Kansans for Fairness |
| $150 | Vern Chesbro, Ottawa | KTRM contributor; former KS Republican Party chair |
| $250 | Charles Clark, Prairie Village | KTRM contributor |
| $100 | Marilyn Cohen, Mission Hills | KFUPE contributor |
| $50 | Clyda Cott, Johnson | Sebelius contributor |
| $100 | Liz Craig, Roeland Park | Contributor to MAIN*PAC,
MAINstream Board (2003-2005); Gene Rardin for State Rep contributor; Republican for Moore; President of Kansas Citizens for Science |
| $150 | William Cutler, Topeka | Contributor to ProKanDo |
| $50 | Raymond Davis, Lawrence | Contributor to Sebelius, Boyda; Appointed by
Sebelius to Kansas Health Policy Board |
| $450 | Janice DeBauge, Emporia | Big Sebelius contributor; Contributor to
Biggs and Morrison; former member of Board of Regents |
| $50 | Valorie Defever, Independence | KTRM and MAIN*PAC contributor; SBOE candidate (2004) |
| $450 | Christine Downey-Schmidt, Inman | Contributor to Sebelius, Carlos Nolla; former Board of Regents; Sebelius appointed to Kansas Arts Commission |
| $100 | Bruce Durkee, Overland Park | Contributor to Sebelius, NARAL |
| $300 | Kathleen Dzewaltowski, Manhattan | Treasurer, "Citzens for a Better Manhattan" (2005) |
| $105 | Hlida Enoch, Lawrence | Contributor to Sebelius |
| $400 | Sharon Forker, Leawood | Contributor to Sebelius, Mainstream; Republican for Moore (2002, 2004) |
| $100 | Sheila Frahm. Colby | Former Lt. Gov.
under Bill Graves; appointed to fill Bob Dole's U.S. Senate seat |
| $100 | Bill Franklin, Prairie Village | KTRM contributor;
former MAINstream Board member; member of Steve Cloud's GOP Club Advisory Board; |
| $100 | Kim Hanson, Leawood | Member of True Blue Women |
| $500 | Helen Healy, Eastborough | ProKanDo contributor |
| $60 | Jerry Hoggatt, Wichita | ProKanDo contributor |
| $150 | Paul Holt, Towanda | Contributed to Educating All Children in Kansas PAC (E-PAC) |
| $250 | Ann Isenberg, Mission Hills | MAIN*PAC, KFUPE,
ProKanDo, DNC contributor; Republican for Moore (2002, 2004) |
| $100 | Norman Jeter, Hays | Contributor to Kansas Democratic Party |
| $250 | Anita Jones, Wichita | Contributor to ProKanDo, Steve Cloud/Jack Ranson's Responsible Republicans for Kansas |
| $100 | Ann Kenney, Leawood | Contributor to MAIN*PAC, Sebelius, ProKanDo; Contributed $1000 to Think Big in favor of bistate tax; Contributed to Clinton's Legal Defense Fund; Republican for Moore (2000, 2002, 2004) |
| $100 | Ruth Kline, Leawood | Contributor to MAIN*PAC, ProKanDo; MAINstream Coalition Advisory Board; Republican for Moore (2000, 2004); wife for former State Rep Phil (single "L") Kline |
| $150 | John Koepke, Topeka | Contributed to Educating All Children in Kansas PAC (E-PAC) |
| $200 | Judith Lair, Piqua | Contributed to Educating All Children in Kansas PAC (E-PAC) |
| $200 | Leslie Lampe, Shawnee | Contributed to MAIN*PAC |
| $100 | Ellen Laner, Mission Hills | Former treasurer
for Democratic Congressman Moore; Republican for Moore (2000, 2002); Contributor to Sebelius, Morrison and KTRM; Contributor to YesYesYes (2000) campaign in JoCo to hide party affiliation in county races; MAINstream President (2003), MAINstream Executive Committee (2006); League of Women Voters |
| $100 | Sondra Langel, Wichita | ProKanDo contributor |
| $100 | Audrey Langworthy, Wichita | Contributor to ProKanDo and host for ProKanDo fundraiser in 2006; former Republican State Senator but contributor to Sebelius, and Bodya; Contributor to KTRM and gave $1000 to Think Big to push for bistate tax; Contributor to Steve Cloud's JoCo Republicans for Education (2004); Steve Cloud's GOP Club Advisory Board; Appointed by Sebelius to Kansas Development Finance Authority; Appointed to Sebelius' Education Policy Team (2003); Wrote letter to Topeka Capital Journal, Kansas City Star with Tim Emert in Support of Sebelius over Shallenburger (2002) |
| $100 | Ellen LeCompte, Lawrence | Contributor to Sebelius, Moore, Kansans for Fairness |
| $100 | Bruce Lerner, Prairie Village | Contributor to MAINstream; Contributor to Chris Biggs for AG (2002); Republican for Moore (2000, 2002, 2004) |
| $100 | Christy Levings, Osawatomie | President, KNEA (2006) |
| $250 | David Lillard, Prairie Village | MAINstream Coalition Executive Board (2007) |
| $5000 | Neal Lintecum, Lawrence | Largest individual contributor. |
| $100 | Eleanor Lowe, Mission Hills | Contributor to MAIN*PAC and MAINstream; Republican for Moore (2000, 2002, 2004); League of Women Voters; former Mainstream President; MAIN*PAC Director (2006) |
| $150 | Barbro Lucas, Fairway | ProKanDo Contributor and host for ProKanDo fundraiser in 2006 |
| $60 | Linda Luckey, Lawrence | former Lawrence Equality Coalition Board Member; Contributed to Kansans for Fairness |
| $250 | Nancy Lusk, Andover | ProKanDo Contributor |
| $100 | Elaine Mann, Overland Park | Contributor to Democrat Dennis Moore for Congress; Contributor to ProKanDo PAC; Contributor to JoCO "YesYesYes" group to hide political affiliations on county offices; JoCo League of Women Voters president (2003) |
| $100 | Royceann Mather, Overland Park | Jim Yonally treasurer (2002-2005); Contributor to Rardin for State Rep, KFUPE, Mainstream, Dennis Moore for Congress; JoCo League of Women Voters president (2007); |
| $200 | Sheryl Mathis, Topeka | KNEA Exec Director |
| $100 | Nancy McBride, Prairie Village | Board of Directors, Planned Parenthood KS/Mid-Missouri (2000) |
| $100 | Charlotte McDonald, Olathe | KTRM contributor; |
| $100 | Harry McDonald, Olathe | KTRM contributor; SBOE candidate in 2006; KFUPE volunteer at State Fair (2006) |
| $200 | Janene McNeil, Manhattan | Contributor to ProKanDo, and Emily's List; Contributor to Kansans for Justice and Equality Project |
| $100 | Shirley Meneilly, Prairie Village | Contributor to Dennis Moore; Republican for Moore (2000, 2002, 2004) |
| $100 | Marjorie Newmark, Lawrence | Contributor to ProKanDo and Sebelius |
| $100 | Vickie Nitsch, Dodge City | KNEA staff; contributor to KNEA |
| $500 | James Quigley, Lenexa | Republican for Moore; $1800 contributor to Democrat Howard Dean for President; husband of "Republican" State Rep Jill Quigley, who is also a Republican for Moore |
| $200 | Robert "Bob" Regnier, Leawood ("Uncle Bob" on his radio commercials) |
Contributor to Sebelius, Morrison, KTRM, and "Think Big" to send Kansas tax dollars to Missouri; Recently elected Chair of Greater Kansas City Chamber of Commerce |
| $100 | Marcia Rinehart, Leawood | MAINstream Coalition Board; Contributor to Morrison for AG, KTRM; Contributor to YesYesYes (2000) campaign in JoCo to hide party affiliation in county races; Former Leawood mayor, and recently appointed to 10th Judicial Nominating Commission; Republican for Moore (2004) |
| $100 | Joseph &
John Robb 110 E Broadway Newton 67114 |
John is an attorney for
"Schools for Fair
Funding" and made a huge amount suing
Kansas for more money for public schools and serving
as a lobbyist for schools.
Both Joseph and John are also contributors to Kansas Traditional Republican Majority (KTRM) and Democrat Paul Morrison. |
| $100 | Gene Schille, Mission Hills | MAINpac and MAINstream Coalition contributor |
| $100 | Ann and Stephen Starch, Wichita | Contributors to ProKanDo |
| $150 | Cheri Stubblefield, Overland Park | Contributor to MAINpac, Democrat Gene Rardin for State Rep |
| $100 | Cynthia Wendt, Leawood | Contributor to Sebelius, Morrison, MAINstream, KFUPE, Greater KC Women's Political Caucus |
| $300 | Barbara Wigger, Prairie Village | Contibutor to MAINstream; Republican for Moore (2000, 2002) |
6. Church affiliations of KAE Board Members
|
The church affiliations given above are ONLY mentioned since they were
listed on the KAE web pages for certain members. Can we
assume that by mentioning only these church groups that KAE is saying
that only certain Lutherans (Tim Cruz, Charles Frickey), Presbyterians
(Sue Ice, Rev Bob Meneilly), and Methodists (Philip Shull, Dr. Robert
Harder) are "OK" Christians and others are not (like the
conservative State Board of Education Board members)? Are all
Kansans Lutherans, Presbyterians or Methodists? Why is KAE
opposing certain "Christians" and supporting only certain
other "Christians"? How is KAE promoting the First
Amendment's guarantee of "Freedom of Religion" when it's
picking sides based on religion? Isn't KAE pushing religion
in the same way they claim the 2006 board was doing? Isn't
KAE being exclusionary of the religion of the majority of Kansans?
Why is KAE excluding most prolife Christians?
Why did KAE even mention church affiliations of their members if they claimed religious affiliation was a problem in 2006 of the SBOE members? KAE is comfortable imposing their political solution based on the religious beliefs of only some Kansans they represent, but how does that "solve" the problem? Why is a "moderate" solution one that is not respectful of everyone's view? Until we find an approach where groups mutually respect each other's views we seem to be in an endless cycle in the "solution" to this problem. For now, we seem to have the best solution that KAE and NEA/KNEA can buy. Unfortunately, a scientifically sound solution to a political problem may only be a temporary solution. Science may not change (much or that quickly), but politics certainly will over time. |
|
|
| efg |
|
|
|
Please send constructive criticism, corrections, or comments to K a n s a s M e a d o w l a r k @ g m a i l . c o m |